Ghosts of BaltimoreThe lost and untold stories of Baltimore

Try an address, a neighborhood, a name or a year, like “Fells Point” or “1904.”

Not sure where to start?

Ben McDonald and the Weight of Being the No. 1 Pick

Baltimore drafted Ben McDonald first overall in 1989. His first major-league start was a shutout, but shoulder trouble cut his career short.

Posted Updated 1 min read

Ben McDonald arrived in Baltimore with the expectations that come with being the first player chosen in the draft. The Orioles selected the LSU pitcher in 1989, and he reached the majors that September. For a club that had lost 107 games in 1988, there was plenty riding on that arm.

His first major-league start gave fans a reason to believe. On July 21, 1990, McDonald shut out the Chicago White Sox on four hits. He won his first five starts, then went on to pitch more than 200 innings in both 1992 and 1993.

1995 Score Ben McDonald
1995 Score Ben McDonald

The comparison that still stings is Frank Thomas, whom Chicago took seventh in the same 1989 draft. But looking backward from a Hall of Fame career makes the choice seem easier than it was. McDonald gave Baltimore substantial work before shoulder trouble shortened his career.

Across nine major-league seasons, McDonald finished with 78 wins, 70 losses and a 3.91 earned-run average. His career ended short of the hopes attached to that first pick, but included two seasons of heavy work in Baltimore’s rotation.

Mike Mussina and Ben McDonald - Sports Illustrated
Mike Mussina and Ben McDonald – Sports Illustrated
The Email

Lost Baltimore stories, in your inbox.

The newest story, plus a few from the archive.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

AI helped research and write this story. Here’s how we use AI.Suggest a correction

Pass it on

Know someone who’d like this?

Send it to them.

Email it

Readers’ favorites

Keep reading