Ghosts of BaltimoreThe lost and untold stories of Baltimore

Try an address, a neighborhood, a name or a year, like “Fells Point” or “1904.”

Not sure where to start?

The Candy Kid and the Tiger Girl: Richard and Margaret Whittemore

The papers made celebrities of the Candy Kid and the Tiger Girl, but we went looking for Robert H. Holtman, the Maryland Penitentiary guard who died after the 1925 escape.

Posted Updated 11 min read

In February 1925, Richard Reese Whittemore broke out of the Maryland Penitentiary in Baltimore. A guard named Robert H. Holtman died of the blow he took during the escape. Eighteen months later, on August 13, 1926, Whittemore was hanged inside the same prison.

In between, the newspapers called him the “Candy Kid” and his wife, Margaret, the “Tiger Girl.” Glenn Stout’s 2021 book, Tiger Girl and the Candy Kid, is a full-length history of the couple. He says the nickname nodded to both Whittemore’s sweet talk and his drug use.

The men arrested with him in New York in March 1926 included the brothers Jacob and Leon Kraemer and Anthony Paladino. Also arrested were Milton “Shuffles” Goldberg and William Unkelbach, whom the papers called “Baltimore Willie.”

The tabloids loved the couple, but the guard Whittemore left lying in the prison yard got far less attention. So we went back to the 1925 and 1926 coverage in the Library of Congress newspaper archive and the Baltimore Sun. We wanted to find him and to sort the record from the tabloid gloss.

The escape that killed a guard

Whittemore was serving a 15-year sentence for robbery. On Friday, February 20, 1925, he struck Holtman on the head and got out of the Maryland Penitentiary. Here’s how a short item in Washington’s Evening Star reported it three days later:

Richard Reese Whittemore, who escaped from the penitentiary Friday, is still at large. Police today said circulars would be sent throughout the country in an effort to apprehend him.

Whittemore, serving a 15-year term for robbery, felled a guard with an iron bar in making his escape. The guard died as a result of a fractured skull.

Holtman died the next day, Saturday, February 21, at 5 p.m. at University Hospital, of a fractured skull, the Sun reported. Before he died he made a statement accusing Whittemore, according to State’s Attorney Herbert R. O’Conor. O’Conor promised to ask the grand jury for a murder indictment.

The warden, Col. Claude B. Sweezey, told the Sun that night: “He died doing his duty, and that is the highest honor that can come to any man at death.”

The Sun gave the fullest picture of Holtman himself. He was 61 and had been born at Ellicott City. He came to Baltimore 19 years before his death to take a job as a guard at the Penitentiary, and he worked there from then on.

He left a widow, Marie J. Holtman, a son, J. Bernard Holtman, and three daughters. The Sun reported that services were set for his home at 316 Harwood Avenue, with Penitentiary guards as pallbearers. He would be buried in Baltimore Cemetery, the paper said.

One more small window comes from the Court of Appeals opinion in the case. During jury selection, a prospective juror said he had “worked under the same employer with him” in the summer of 1901. The juror saw Holtman two or three times a week then “and liked him.”

The defense asked the judge to remove that juror for bias. The judge declined, and the defense then struck him with one of its own challenges. Holtman is listed today on Maryland’s roll of fallen correctional officers, with an end of watch of February 21, 1925.

The weapon changes depending on who’s telling it. The 1925 report says an iron bar, and later stories say an iron pipe or a lead pipe. An inmate trusty named John Bowie was lined up to testify that he saw Whittemore hit Holtman with an iron bar.

The United Press said Whittemore then walked through the prison hospital and out into the street. Whittemore’s own version, given in New York in March 1926, was that he took Holtman’s pistols and keys and opened the prison gate.

The Sun‘s 1926 summary explains how he got close to the guard. Whittemore had burned his arm a few days after he arrived. On the day of the escape he was sent from the shoe factory to the prison hospital, where Holtman let him into the building.

Minutes later the trusty, John Thomas Bowie, sounded the alarm. Holtman lay unconscious on the brick floor of the yard, and his keys, pocketbook and pistol were missing. From Bowie, the Sun said, police learned that Whittemore had gone out “through a door in the prison wall, which he opened with the keys.”

A year on the run

Whittemore was free for 13 months, and most of what police later pinned on his gang happened in New York. Police there tied the gang to a string of jewelry holdups.

One was a diamond robbery at Fifth Avenue and 48th Street on January 11, 1926, where two merchants were blackjacked in the street. The AP put that haul at $170,000 in one story and $200,000 in another.

The deadliest crime police attributed to the gang happened in Buffalo on October 29, 1925. An armored car carrying money from the Federal Reserve Bank pulled up at the Bank of Buffalo, a branch of the Marine Trust Co. Gunmen opened fire without warning.

Driver Charles Clifford was killed, guard Louis M. Yarington was fatally wounded and messenger John Meyers was shot in the arm. The robbers got away with $93,000.

Marine Trust Company of Buffalo notice offering a $10,000 reward after the October 29, 1925, robbery and murder at its Bank of Buffalo branch
The Marine Trust Company of Buffalo offered a $10,000 reward after the robbery and killings outside its Bank of Buffalo branch on October 29, 1925. 1925 notice; public domain.

Police suspected the gang in other killings they never proved in court. One was Simon Gilden, a Baltimore man found dead at Trinity churchyard in lower Manhattan in December 1925.

Back in Baltimore, bandits shot paymaster Emanuel Berlin and Patrolman Patrick Durkin during a $16,300 payroll holdup at the Western Maryland Dairy on February 24, 1926. The Evening Star said both men’s wounds were dangerous but not necessarily fatal. We didn’t find a later report on how they fared.

Baltimore detectives went looking for links to the gang after the March arrests. In May 1926, back in Baltimore to face trial, Whittemore told police that Unkelbach had been in town at the time.

Whittemore added that “it is the kind of a job he would likely do.” Nobody we found was ever convicted of that holdup.

Caught on Broadway

According to the AP, the arrests began with a chance sighting. Early on the morning of March 19, 1926, two detectives in a police car grew suspicious of three men leaving a supper club.

An automobile chase and fight along Broadway followed. One of the men, who gave his first name as Robert and an address in Cleveland, was Whittemore.

His wife was picked up as she was about to leave the city. She was 22 and, the AP said, registered at a hotel as Mrs. Margaret Collins.

The Washington Times, which called her the “Tiger Kid,” said she first gave her name as Miss Margaret Collins of Cleveland. The paper also described what detectives found in her luggage:

…in her possession were found two trunk checks and while en route to the police station the detectives stopped off and secured the trunks and therein they found two pistols, boxes of cartridges, denim masks and other evidence that the owners of the trunks were engaged in criminal depredations.

The AP’s version of the trunk was a little different: three loaded revolvers, a quantity of cartridges and three black silk masks. The AP also reported that Margaret told police her husband was a robber.

In the same breath she said she had toured the country with him, staying at expensive hotels and riding in high-priced cars. Yet she believed he was a traveling salesman, she said, and she was going to “stick by him.” That salesman story sat awkwardly next to the pistols and masks in her trunks.

The Tiger Girl’s deal

Stout writes that Margaret Messler married Whittemore in October 1921, when she was 18. Little more than a week after the wedding, he writes, Whittemore was arrested for stealing from a neighbor’s home. The United Press told it differently in 1926, saying he married her after the guard’s killing.

Within a week of the 1926 arrests, the couple’s story had become a romance in the papers. From his cell, Whittemore offered the Manhattan district attorney’s office a trade, as the AP reported on March 26, 1926:

“If they will release my wife, turn her out on the street, I’ll startle New York with what I can tell,” he says. “I’ll give up the works and astonish the city.”

Later that day the couple met in District Attorney Joab H. Banton’s office for the first time since their arrest. The United Press told readers that the handcuffed “Candy Kid” managed to slip an arm around her and kiss her. The UP also reported that Banton had agreed to drop the charges against Mrs. Whittemore if her husband told his story.

On March 30, Banton withdrew the offer, saying Whittemore’s confession hadn’t checked out and that Mrs. Whittemore would not be freed. On April 10, the AP reported that she had agreed to tell Assistant District Attorney Pecora what she knew herself.

On April 12, the UP said she was being released “in exchange for information” against Jacob and Leon Kraemer, with a robbery indictment against her dropped. The AP’s story on the morning of the hanging told it differently, crediting her release to her husband’s bargain. Our reading is that the April reporting, written as it happened, is the better guide, and that she talked.

Cheers in Buffalo, a verdict in Baltimore

Buffalo authorities had lodged warrants for him in the armored car killings. They got Whittemore first and tried him only for the murder of Charles Clifford. The jury deliberated for 29 hours and was discharged on the night of April 27, 1926, without agreeing.

When the result was announced, the Washington Times reported, the crowd cheered and shouted “Hurrah for Whittemore” and “Hurrah for Tiger Lil!” Margaret “almost swooned,” the paper said, then broke down in tears.

Buffalo never got the chance to retry him. New York City and Buffalo authorities stood aside. Baltimore State’s Attorney O’Conor, who said Maryland had “an open-and-shut case against him,” brought him home.

Washington Times headline: Baltimore and N.Y. Seek Candy Kid, April 28, 1926
The Washington Times on April 28, 1926, the morning after the Buffalo jury failed to agree. Public domain. (LOC)

His Baltimore trial opened in May before Judge Eugene O’Dunne. His court-appointed lawyer shared his name with Baltimore’s most famous writer: Edgar Allan Poe.

Whittemore took the stand, admitted striking Holtman and called it self-defense, but the details of that claim shifted. In New York he had said he’d been told Holtman had shot prisoners before. Nothing we read backed up that accusation against a dead man.

At trial his lawyer said Holtman was reaching for his pistol when Whittemore hit him. When the UP summarized the case at sentencing, it said Whittemore had claimed the guard reached for a blackjack.

On May 21, 1926, the jury found him guilty of murder in the first degree. When foreman J. H. Bauer read the verdict, the Evening Star reported, Margaret fell unconscious into the arms of her father-in-law.

On June 10, Judge O’Dunne sentenced him to hang. Whittemore’s only comment, per the UP, was “I’m still not guilty of premeditated murder.”

August 13, 1926

The Court of Appeals upheld the conviction on July 8, 1926. A last petition for a writ of habeas corpus was dismissed in Baltimore City Court just days before the execution.

Margaret, meanwhile, was telling the United Press she would not survive him. “I will die; cannot live without him,” she said in late July.

Several hours before the execution, she and Whittemore’s father said goodbye to him through a heavy fine-meshed screen around the death cell. She left the prison weeping. Outside, the UP found crowds treating the night almost like a fair:

Crowds gathered in almost carnival spirit last night outside the prison where Richard Reese Whittemore was hanged. Enterprising business men reaped large profits thru the sale of hot dogs, bottled soda near-beer, water, ice cream and candy bars to the promenading throngs.

Just after midnight on Friday, August 13, Whittemore stepped onto the scaffold inside the penitentiary, near the spot, the UP said, where he had killed Holtman. The AP recorded his last words as “I wish to say good-by, the best I could wish anybody.” Among the witnesses, the UP noted, was H. L. Mencken.

The Sun put the hanging at 12:08 a.m. and printed the last words a little differently: “I wish to say good-by. That is the best I can wish anyone.”

About 75 people watched, among them 31 newspapermen and 25 policemen. More than 1,000 people waited on the sidewalks outside.

The last appeal had failed the day before. Lawyer G. L. Pendleton, hired by Margaret and Whittemore’s father, took the case to Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes at his summer home in Beverly Farms, Massachusetts. Holmes refused to stay the execution.

Margaret, her mother and his father, Rawlings V. Whittemore, saw him for the last time that afternoon. When his body was cut down, the Sun reported, a newspaper photograph of his wife and a clipped poem hung on a cord around his neck, directly over his heart.

Evening Star portrait of Richard Reese Whittemore under the heading Dies on Gallows, August 13, 1926
The Evening Star ran this portrait with its story of the hanging on August 13, 1926. Public domain. (LOC)

Sorting the legend from the record

Much of the Candy Kid legend rested on round numbers. The gang’s total haul was usually put at “about $1,000,000,” a figure from the police and the district attorney. The four jewelry robbery confessions the AP described on March 21, 1926, totaled $300,000.

Murders were laid on the gang by the half-dozen, but the only murder conviction we found was for Robert Holtman’s death. The Buffalo killings of Clifford and Yarington were never resolved in court.

The record on the rest of the gang is muddled too. The UP reported in August 1926 that the Kraemer brothers were serving 20 to 40 years and that Paladino and Unkelbach, who both turned informer, were still awaiting sentence. The AP said the same day that all the male gangsters had received prison terms in New York.

The nicknames varied as well. Margaret was the “Tiger Kid” in one paper, the “Tiger Girl” in most and “Tiger Lil” to the Buffalo crowd. Whittemore’s age shifts from story to story, and the papers didn’t agree on the name of the nightclub he left before his arrest.

As for Margaret, she dropped out of the news. Stout writes that she lived in relative obscurity and died at home in 1993. Her death notice in the Baltimore Sun, he writes, didn’t mention her early life and misspelled her name.

Robert Holtman’s name, meanwhile, is still on the state’s honor roll, more than a century after the blow that started all of this.

The Email

Liked this one? Get more tomorrow.

Lost Baltimore stories in your inbox most mornings: the newest, plus a few from the archive.

Stories like these, most mornings
  • This storyThe Candy Kid and the Tiger Girl: Richard and Margaret Whittemore
  • The French Consulate at Charles and Centre
  • Bernard “Boompy” Logue and Baltimore’s Wooden Bicycle

Free. Unsubscribe anytime.

We use AI to help research, write and edit stories across our sites. Here’s how we use AI.Suggest a correction

Read nextSam Crane, the Former Oriole Convicted of a 1929 Double MurderHow Sam Crane went from Jack Dunn’s Orioles to two murder convictions in Pennsylvania, and why Connie Mack spent years trying to get him out.Keep reading6 min read
On the Atlas

See where this happened.

954 Forrest St

Open the map